Claremont Insider: Measure R
Showing posts with label Measure R. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Measure R. Show all posts

Friday, January 9, 2009

More Local Project Construction News

MTA BAIT-AND-SWITCH

Reporter Dan Abendschein had an article in the San Gabriel Valley Tribune yesterday that said that the Gold Line Foothill Extension Authority may have to wait until 2011 before it starts to get any of that promised revenue from the half-cent sales tax increase L. A. County voters approved last November with Measure R.

No surprise there. The county's Metropolitan Transportation Authority sold the sales tax increase to voters in our area with the promise that the MTA would come through with money for the Gold Line extension. However, the MTA also ended up costing the Gold Line $320 million in federal money that it could have qualified for had the MTA simply come through with a matching grant of $80 million. Instead, the MTA denied the Gold Line that money and promised to come through with $735 million if Measure R passed.

Cynics, including the Insider, thought that once the sales tax increase was approved, the MTA, headed by Los Angeles Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa, would renege on the promise and would give West L. A.'s Subway-to-the-Sea first dibs on any money. And that may be exactly what's happening now.

Westsiders would say that their needs are more pressing, but San Gabriel Valley residents have argued that traffic in this area is every bit as bad as West L. A./Santa Monica and that the SGV doesn't receive nearly as much in benefits as it pays out to fund things like Measure R. Residents in our area would also argue that whereas the Gold Line is ready to go, the Subway-to-the-Sea is still in the planning stages.

And, no matter what your position is on which project is more deserving, the bait-and-switch tactics the MTA and Villaraigosa used to get Measure R passed certainly speaks volumes about the integrity (or lack thereof) involved here.

Dan Abendschein's article gave some of the details:

The Gold Line Foothill Extension may not be receive significant Measure R funding until 2011, and may not be completed until 2017, if the county's transit agency passes a proposed long-range plan.

The Gold Line Foothill Extension Authority, the independent agency charged with building the line, estimated a completion date of 2013 last month, after the passage of Measure R, the half-cent sales tax increase designed to fund county transportation projects.

If the long range plan is approved, the Foothill Extension Authority would probably not even see any tax money until 2013, according to Habib Balian, the group's director, who reviewed a report outlining the plan.

"There is not a lot of detail in the report, so we still have a lot of questions," said Balian. "But this action would appear to delay our funding."

David Yale, the Deputy Executive Officer of Regional Programming for the Metropolitan Transportation Agency said the Extension Authority would start to receive serious levels of funding in 2011.

The project could see "a little bit of funding" in 2010 from 2009 sales tax revenues, said Yale. MTA previously said the Gold Line would begin getting funding in 2010, but did not specify how much.

PADUA PARK FUNDING DELAY CONFIRMED

The Daily Bulletin's Wes Woods II had an article that verified what we had wondered about the lack of construction activity at the Padua Ave. Park site in Northeast Claremont.

As you'll recall, last month we wrote about the fact that the San Gabriel and Los Angeles Rivers and Mountains Conservancy, the state agency that gave Claremont a $850,000 grant for the Padua Park project, was unable to come through with the grant because of the state's financial situation.

The state has placed a moratorium on the sale of bonds until its potential $42 billion deficit can be fixed. Woods explained in his article:
Belinda Faustinos, executive director of the San Gabriel & Lower Los Angeles Rivers and Mountains Conservancy, noted Friday that a statewide freeze was ordered on bond funds Dec. 17.

Faustinos said there would be a meeting Tuesday with the Pooled Money Investment Board.

That board determines the amount of bond funds that can be sold and therefore how much cash is available for bond projects.

"Unless they authorize the sale of bonds, there is no money to spend for those types of projects," Faustinos said.

Faustinos said there is not expected to be much progress unless the state comes up with a solution to the budget crisis.

Woods also quoted Claremont Mayor Ellen Taylor as saying:
"We're trying in many different ways to approach it," Mayor Ellen Taylor said Friday. Taylor was upset the money was frozen but said the council has "lots of plans. I can't go into the details right now, they're in the infancy stage. There have been no firm decisions made."

In other words, the city will get this done somehow, some way, even if we have to pay for the whole thing ourselves by shuffling money around in the old Claremont shell game. The City can put off paying police officers the pay and benefits it promised them, but it can come through with $850,000 for Ellen's pet project. As one friend of the Insider remarked about that prospect, "That's sick."

No, that's Claremont.

Thursday, November 6, 2008

Foothill Cities Blog Blamed for Passage of LA County Transit Measure R

In a wave of bitter recrimination, opponents of the Metropolitan Transit Authority's Measure R, another half cent sales tax increase for transportation, blamed the now-defunct Foothill Cities Blog for the defeat.

"We were counting on Foothill Cities to be there when we needed it," lamented a chastened Supervisor Michael D. Antonovich. "There was nothing in Measure R for the San Gabriel Valley, and we frankly expected Foothill Cities to point that out to its wide readership. But Foothill Cities has been silent on this issue for more than six weeks."

In fact Foothill Cities has been off the air for almost seven weeks. A lonely note claiming a server crash is all that now greets the visitor to thefcblog.com. According to Publius, the founder of the Foothill Cities Blog, "This was a major technological error. Centinel is on it." Sure.

Mayor Ellen Taylor of Claremont, secretly very happy to have another half-percent added to her shopping cart, making Claremont still less competitive with Montclair Plaza, nonetheless put on her game face: "We just don't understand why the voters would have done this. I published a letter with all the arguments in the Daily Bulletin and even in the Claremont Courier. If only the Foothill Cities Blog had covered it. This is really, really sad."

Pomona City Council member George Hunter, whose name was left off the ballot argument in a conspiracy that included Los Angeles County Registrar-Recorder Dean C. Logan, piled on. "Foothill Cities bears a heavy responsibility for the passage of this measure. We had counted on that blog, and it wasn't there." Councilmember Hunter called us from his car with this quote; he was stuck in traffic on the 71 at Mission Blvd in Pomona, an Intersection From Hell that will not be addressed by Measure R funds.

As of this writing Measure R appears to have passed with a mere 18,080 vote margin over the 2/3 of the 2.4 million voters who inked a preference, one way or the other, for the measure. It is unclear whether late absentee or provisional ballots could possibly change the outcome. But with the aforementioned Registrar-Recorder Dean C. Logan counting the votes, no worries; right?

Los Angeles Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa, a key supporter of Measure R, was ecstatic. "Now we can build the subway to the sea for my Westside supporters, and to hell with those hicks in the San Gabriel Valley. Who wants to go there, anyway? Gold Line Schmold Line." He added, "I'm just grateful we weren't up against the Foothill Cities Blog."

Supervisors Gloria Molina and Don Knabe issued a joint statement blaming the Foothill Cities Blog. "A shocking abdication of responsibility," the statement said.

____________________

All quotes in this post were made up.

Wednesday, November 5, 2008

Down-ballot Election Results

A smattering of some of the down-ballot results of interest to Claremont. It's hard to get reliable links to the official elections websites, so take these with a grain of salt. (Results compiled between 6 and 7 a.m. on Wednesday, November 5)

David Dreier, incumbent congressman from the 26th district, which includes Claremont, appears to have withstood a challenge from Democrat Russ Warner. With 318 of 469 precincts reporting, Dreier had 53.5% of the vote to Warner's 40.2%. We commented here on one of the mail pieces opposing Dreier. The Federal Election Commission has now posted the campaign finance disclosure from the Blue America PAC for the hit piece. It cost $19,652.44 to prepare and mail.

click on image to enlarge

See here for latest results in Dreier's race.

In a district adjacent to Claremont, the north Pomona division of Three Valleys Municipal Water District, carpenter John Mendoza appears to have trounced incumbent Fred Lantz, 55% t0 45%. This has a lot of the look of the election two years ago when Xavier Alvarez took his seat from the then-incumbent: a relative unknown versus a long-time water wonk. We don't know much about Mendoza, he has no website and didn't fill out the League of Women Voters Smartvoter information. Mendoza didn't come off all that well in an article in last month's San Gabriel Valley Tribune, where he rapped the current board for "making a lot of decisions about water but they are just sitting there at the top, collecting pay and benefits." The article goes on to say that Mendoza, if elected, would still collect benefits, "but I won't take advantage of them." Huh?

Lantz is husband of Pomona councilmember Paula Lantz. Maybe some of our friends in Lincoln Park (Meg?) can elaborate on this race. [Update: John Clifford over on M-M-M-My Pomona points out that John Mendoza not only ran for and won the Three Valleys seat, but also ran unsuccessfully for a city council seat in this election, losing to Stephen Atcheley but edging out the Daily Bulletin-endorsed Querubin. Mendoza was busy; he also sponsored an increase in the Utility Tax in Pomona, Measure PC, which failed by nearly three to one.]

In incomplete returns, 21 of 25 precincts reporting, Glenn Southard nemesis Michael Wilson is trailing by 900 votes in Indio's city council election. Try this link for updated results--no guarantees it will work. The margin against Wilson has widened as more returns have come in. According to the Desert Sun, Wilson was outspent by the two leaders by four or five to one. Leader Wilson raised more than $60,000; incumbent Watson raised some $45,000, and Wilson raised around $12,000.

Measure R, the new Los Angeles County half-cent sales tax increase, squeaked by 67.4% to 32.6%. It needed 2/3 to pass. It was opposed by Claremont Mayor Ellen Taylor, the Claremont City Council, and many local politicos. It's a win for LA Mayor Anthony Villaraigosa and the MTA and the Westside. Whether we will see much out here in the San Gabriel Valley is doubtful, according to opponents.

Norma Torres, police dispatcher and Pomona mayor, and "Friend of Xavier", is on her way to the State Assembly. With about 2/3 of the votes counted, she leads by more than 15,000 votes, 60.6% to 32.8% for Wendy Maier.

Anthony Adams and Bob Huff both are leading comfortably in their races as Claremont's State Assemblyman and State Senator, respectively.

For you national political junkies, here is an interesting set of maps on the Obama-McCain race, with analysis.

Monday, November 3, 2008

East vs. West on Measure R

The Los Angeles Times had an article last Saturday that discussed the LA County Measure R sales tax ballot measure. The article focused on the differences between LA's Westside residents and those in the eastern LA County. (Politicians in outlying county areas like Lancaster or the San Gabriel Valley have argued against Measure R, saying that the money generated would go disproportionately to Los Angeles, particularly the Westside "Subway-to-the-Sea".)

The article, by Times writer Steven Hymon, also made use of Hymon's interview with Claremont Mayor Ellen Taylor, who, along with the rest of the Claremont City Council, has opposed the measure. The article also noted that although it is true that West LA does suffer epic traffic congestion, so does the San Gabriel Valley:

Despite the widely held view that the Westside has the county's worst gridlock, traffic statistics from the California Department of Transportation and the Freeway Performance Measurement System at UC Berkeley suggest that drivers on the east side of town aren't doing much better.

Although parts of the 10 and 405 freeways carry more than 300,000 vehicles daily -- a very high load -- so does the 210 Freeway in Pasadena. And in the last two months, the two freeway bottlenecks where motorists experienced the worst delays during the morning commute were in the San Gabriel Valley, on the 10 and 210.

Ranked four and five on the list: the westbound 10 at Robertson and La Cienega boulevards, respectively.

Measure R has generated much excitement on the Westside because it is considered the first concrete funding step for a Wilshire Boulevard subway, which for decades has been the Holy Grail for those trying to reduce congestion.

The subway could get $4.1 billion from the ballot item. That makes the proposal the largest Measure R project, with the subway possibly accounting for 10% or more of the funds that the sales tax is expected to raise over its 30-year life span.

That has led critics to say that Measure R is a thinly disguised plan by Los Angeles Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa to secure subway funding at the expense of everyone else.

Some San Gabriel Valley officials are upset that an extension of the Gold Line from Pasadena was denied $80 million in seed money this summer by the Villaraigosa-led board of the Metropolitan Transportation Authority. Measure R provides $735 million for the project, but backers say it is not enough for the line to reach Montclair -- their goal -- and they don't believe they will get the money anyway.

Friday, October 31, 2008

Transportation Friday

We've got more transportation news today, beginning with the Claremont Trolley, which began service yesterday. The free, trackless trolley will run three days per week, Thursdays through Saturdays, from 11am to 11pm and will now cost an estimated $1,290,596 for the three-year trial, up from the original estimate of $887,000. The city is estimating the trolley will average 15 riders per hour.

The trolley is being paid for with money Claremont receives from state transportation bond money, even though it has been described by city officials as an economic development project rather than as a transportation project (it supposedly encourages shoppers in different areas of the Claremont Village and Village Expansion).

The Daily Bulletin's Wes Woods II covered the trolley unveiling:

CLAREMONT - City officials and residents on Thursday celebrated the Claremont Village Trolley with a barbershop quartet, christening and free cake and punch.

"I think having a trolley will make the downtown attractive" to those who live outside Claremont, said resident Ping Chang, 42, who rode the trolley for the first time with her 4-year-old daughter, Tiffany.

For Community Services Director Scott Carrol, this is exactly what he believes will happen, as the trolley "promotes economic development in the Village," he said.

To welcome the start of the free trolley service on Thursday morning, Mayor Ellen Taylor spoke to city officials and residents at the Claremont Depot on First Street.

The event was the culmination of events that started with the City Council's approval in January of using transportation money to fund the new service for three years.

The Bulletin's David Allen also had a column on the trolley. Allen seemed skeptical of the project's success, and the column's headline is "Not All Aboard 'Trolley.'" Allen also managed to fit quotes from a current and a former Claremont mayor into the piece:

....Mayor Taylor is already a fan.

"It's very cute," Taylor said. "Very Claremont."

And also very Victoria Gardens, I told her.[SNOB ALERT - CI ed.]

"Do they have one?" Taylor asked. "I never go there."

The "trolley" was about to depart for its third trip. I climbed aboard. It has arched windows, wooden slat seats and straps for anyone who stands. But it also has tires and a bus driver.

A few passersby gave us curious looks. At Bonita and Yale, two women jumped up and down and took photos. Outside the Back Abbey pub on Oberlin, an employee watched quizzically before giving us a wave.

I rarely walk along First, so it was educational to learn the Peyton Grey clothing store is gone. With Chloe & Hunter, that's two recent closures in the Village Square. Oh, if only they could have hung on until the "trolley" started!

Moments later the vehicle was back at the depot, disgorging a columnist. I say, disgorging a columnist.

Former mayor Karen Rosenthal, who rode the faux trolley earlier, was lingering.

"I don't know who's going to ride it," Rosenthal admitted. "Maybe if you park in the Metrolink lot. But if you park in the Village, you could walk three blocks to the trolley, or you could walk three blocks to where you want to be.

"The ones who'll ride it," she added conspiratorially, "are the people who really need to be walking."

Queen Ellen (left) also received a mention in LA Times writer Steve Hymon's Bottleneck Blog. Hymon caught Taylor's opinion piece against LA County's Measure R, the proposed half-cent sales tax increase that would fund transportation projects. Hymon spoke with Her Highness:
I also spoke to Claremont Mayor Ellen Taylor earlier today. She recently wrote a scathing opinion piece against Measure R that ran in the papers in the San Gabriel Valley. She doesn't believe the Gold Line Foothill Extension receives enough funds in the spending plan to get it to Claremont and Montclair -- the plan guarantees it $735 million -- and, equally important, she doesn't believe the money that the Gold Line is promised would arrive in any kind of timely fashion.

I posed this traffic question to her: What's it like in the Valley these days? Her answer:
It's miserable. I’ve lived in Claremont for 30 years and traffic has gotten much worse -- to the point that we don’t go into L.A. anymore. That’s not good for me. I like a full life where you experience stuff. We’ll go to a concert on Sunday afternoon [in Los Angeles] rather than Saturday night because it’s easier to get in and out...

We’re like the bologna in the bread here. And they keep building. You take the 210 east and all you see is roofs and they’re building them without building the infrastructure.
That's a fascinating quote. Why? In early 2007, Times columnist Steve Lopez wrote a piece about how bad Westside traffic is, with quotes from one resident saying they too no longer tried to attend cultural events in downtown L.A. (The Lopez column led to the creation of the Bottleneck Blog). Taylor is essentially saying the same thing, but from the other side of Los Angeles County.



Thursday, October 30, 2008

Measure R Goes to the Voters

LA Times transportation writer and blogger Steve Hymon has an article describing Measure R, the LA Metropolitan Transportation Authority's half-cent county sales tax increase ballot measure. The measure is on next Tuesday's Los Angeles County ballot.

Measure R's potential revenue is supposed to fund traffic and transportation projects such as the so-called Subway-to-the-Sea on LA's westside. The measure has been opposed by some San Gabriel Valley groups and politicians who argue that the money generated would be not be evenly distributed and is unfairly LA-centric.

The article lays out the measure's supporters and opponents:

Who is for and against Measure R?

There is a healthy list of elected officials on both sides of the issue. Editorials among daily newspapers have varied -- The Times, the Daily News, the Daily Breeze and La Opinion are for Measure R and the Press-Telegram, the San Gabriel Valley Tribune and the Antelope Valley Press are against, to name a few.

The Los Angeles County Federation of Labor and the Los Angeles Area Chamber of Commerce support it.

Among prominent politicians, Los Angeles Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa, county Supervisor Zev Yaroslavsky and Assemblyman Mike Feuer (D-Los Angeles) have been the most vocal proponents.

Supervisors Mike Antonovich, Don Knabe and Gloria Molina have been fighting the measure, saying the MTA's spending plan favors the Westside and denies other parts of the county their fair share of sales tax revenues.

The MTA and Measure R supporters rebut that, pointing to a variety of projects that would be built in different parts of the county.

Claremont Mayor Ellen Taylor recently had an opinion piece in the Claremont Courier that argued against the sales tax proposal. Taylor mentioned the MTA decision earlier this year to deny $80 million in MTA funds to the Gold Line Foothill Extension with the promise of Measure R funds. The trouble was that the the MTA's failure to fund the $80 million resulted in the Gold Line Extension being denied $320 million in federal funds for the project. The feds were requiring MTA to supply the $80 million as matching money.

Instead, MTA is dangling the prospect of $735 million from the Measure R honeypot for the Gold Line. However, there is no guarantee that LA Mayor Antonio Villarigosa, who is the primary force behind Measure R, won't raid the promised Gold Line funds to fund other projects in his city, including the westside subway. Taylor's article states that "the last time the MTA committed mass transit funds to the San Gabriel Valley was nearly 3 decades ago," so according to line of thinking, there is probably no reason to believe that the MTA would suddenly change 30 years of behavior once the election is over.

It is more than a little ironic, though, to see Taylor and the city of Claremont having to fight a much larger governmental entity. Karma's a bear to deal with, as Taylor may be learning by getting a little of the ol' Taylor treatment thrown back at her. There are always bigger fish in the local agency sea, and one would hope that Taylor and the city would remember the experience of being unfairly snubbed and ignored the next time a Claremont area resident comes before them with a objections to a city project or initiative.