Claremont Insider: Golden State Water
Showing posts with label Golden State Water. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Golden State Water. Show all posts

Thursday, November 17, 2011

Hargrave Profile

Hal Hargrave, the fellow who organized Monday's meeting for Claremont residents to discuss Golden State Water Co.'s never-ending rate hikes, is profiled in this month's edition of Southwest Airline's Spirit Magazine.  The article also mentions Hal's son, Hal Jr., who was left a quadraplegic after a 2008 auto accident and who founded the non-profit Be Perfect Foundation, which provides support to people who've had spinal cord injuries:

Click to Enlarge

Meetings and Events Around Town

There are a couple upcoming meetings the civic-minded among you might want to attend.

  • The City Council will hold a goal-setting workshop this Saturday beginning at 9am.  Come on out and tell the council what you think our top priorities should be:

    (from the City's website):
    Council Workshop
    9:00 AM
    City Council Chambers
    225 W. Second Street
    Claremont
    (909) 399-5460
    The City council will meet to discuss projects and priorities to allow staff to draft a work plan. This workshop is open to the public.


  • On December 6, the California Public Utilities Commission pays a visit to Claremont's Taylor Hall to hear public comment on Golden State Water Co.'s application for a rate increase.  There will be an afternoon and an evening session:

    Public Hearing on Water Rate Increase on December 6

    The California Public Utilities Commission will hold a Public Hearing on the Golden State Water Company proposed rate increase on December 6 at 2pm and 6pm at Taylor Hall. An Administrative law judge will preside over the hearing and all comments will be included in the General Rate Case.

    Golden State Water has filed for a 27% rate increase for 2012 with smaller increases in 2013, and 2014. The public may comment or protest the rate increase at the public hearing, by e-mail, or writing to the Public Advisor's Office. All public comments are provided to the CPUC Commissioners and Administrative Law Judge assigned to the proceedings.

    Please send all comments to:

    Public Advisor's Office
    320 West 4th St. Ste. 500
    Los Angeles, CA 90013
    or via e-mail to public.advisor.la@cpuc.ca.gov

    Visit the Golden State Water Website


    • The first weekend in December brings us Claremont's annual Christmas Holiday Promenade and Tree Lighting:

      Holiday Promenade & Tree Lighting 2011

      The City of Claremont invites you to an evening filled with live music, festive storefronts, a magnificent tree lighting ceremony and more. The Claremont Village, the area's ultimate shopping destination, will transform into a holiday wonderland where the young and young at heart can enjoy the festivities. The Holiday Promenade will include live entertainment throughout the Village as well as an opportunity to take a photo with Santa Claus.

      You won't want to miss this magical Claremont event. Please join us Friday, December 2nd, from 5-8 p.m. at the Claremont Village Holiday Promenade and Tree Lighting. Enjoy the festive atmosphere and remember to shop Claremont this holiday season.

      For more information please contact us at (909) 399-5490 or visit us at www.ci.claremont.ca.us.


    • And, also in December, the Gypsies Sisters Art Show, having found a new home, will hold their December sale the same weekend as the tree lighting:

      THE GYPSY SISTERS ART SHOW has finally found a home and will be pulling up and parking at the UCC church on Harrison and Harvard Aves. in Claremont. The 31 Gypsies complete with their wonderfully creative art will be settling in down in the basement which faces Harrison Ave. on Friday, December 2 from 4-9, on Saturday, December 3 from 10-8 and on Sunday, December 4 from 10-5. Their wide variety of arts and crafts include quilts, weavings, dolls, clothing, ceramics, jewelry, glass, paintings, handmade books, collages, photographs, prints, purses, metal sculptures, paper sculpture, artistic boxes and bowls and a psychic.  The Gypsy Sisters and their brothers have been coming to Claremont twice a year for more than 18 years.  Please join them for a relaxing visit and some exciting shopping.

    Sunday, November 13, 2011

    Water Rate Pain

    Yesterday's Claremont Courier carried a small ad announcing a "Resident's Meeting [sic]" 6pm tomorrow at Apex Imaging Services, located at 720 Indigo Ct. in Pomona. The ad's title said, "CLAREMONTERS AGAINST OUTRAGEOUS WATER RATES! Golden State Water STOP RIPPING US OFF!!!"

    Click to Enlarge

    The ad was apparently placed by Hal Hargrave, who recently had a letter to the Courier complaining of our water rates. It also pointed readers to the group's Facebook page.

    Residents planning on attending tomorrow's meeting are asked to bring a copy of their latest water bill. The meeting's goal is to "set a plan of action to fight Golden State Water."

    A noble goal indeed, and one we support. Golden State Water and its parent company, American States Water Co., certainly do a great job of playing the Public Utility Commission rate game by, every three or so years, asking for huge rate increases to cover infrastructure repairs that we're not sure are ever completed. (Did they ever get around to upgrading the water tank up by Claraboya after the water presure failed during the 2003 Grand Prix Fire?)

    The PUC, in all its wisdom, shows how fair its judgment is by chopping down the rate increases into digestible chunks - 20%, say, over three years.

    Incidentally, Golden State is playing the same game elsewhere in Southern California: Ojai, Orange County, and the high desert.

    Of course, thanks to regionalized water rates, Claremont's rate hikes are tied to the Bartow-Victorville area. As we've written in the past, Claremont's water rates got lumped together with Barstow's back in 1998 when the water company (then known as Southern California Water Co.) asked for the rates to be regionalized.  Then-City Manager Glenn Southard claimed to have worked out a great deal for the City, getting discounted rates for municipal water use, along with SCWC leasing the City's rights to 535 acre-feet of ground water per year.   In return, the City signed off on SCWC's regionalization request.

    Ironically, in the current fight against rising water rates, the ratepayers' best friend may just be the City of Claremont and other affected municipalities, whose city attorneys will be needed to make a coordinated fight against Golden State Water, whose main goal has always seemed to be to ensure a steady dividend stream to its stockholders, who in turn reward GSW execs with huge salaries and bonuses.

    Wednesday, November 2, 2011

    Upcoming Events

    Some of the events happening this week in our fair city:

    THURSDAY NIGHT WATERWORKS

    Speaking of cartels, Claremont's water supplier, Golden State Water Co., is holding an open house tomorrow evening at the new Claremont University Consortium Administrative Campus Center.   Here's your chance to hear the latest GSWC propaganda in support of their most recently requested rate hikes.   You can get an earful about how all that extra money you're paying for water is going straight into the pockets of water company shareholders improving Claremont's water supply infrastructure.

    Here's what the City's website has to say about the event:

    Golden State Water Family Open House (Nov 1, 2011)

    Golden State Water will host an open house on November 3, 2011 from 5:30 - 7:30 pm at the Claremont University Consortium Administrative Campus Center. This is your opportunity to learn more about your water provider's plans for your area. Golden State Watr employees will staff booths about its general rate case application, water use efficiency, planned improvements, water costs, and water quality. The Campus Center is located a 101 South Mills Avenue.


    WEEKEND BOTANIC GARDEN PLANT SALE

    The Rancho Santa Ana Botanic Garden is holding its fall plant sale this weekend.  Saturday morning until 11am is reserved for RSABG members.  After that, anyone can get in.

    RSABG is located at 1500 N. College Ave. in Claremont.  That's on the north side of Foothill Blvd. between Indian Hill and Mills Ave.  Here's what RSABG's website has to say:

    Fall Plant Sale

    November 5 and 6


    Join us for this spectacular annual event featuring the largest and most exciting collection of California native and California appropriate plants around!

    Rancho Santa Ana Botanic Garden's 33nd annual Fall Plant Sale on Saturday and Sunday, November 5 and 6, 2011. Autumn is the best time to plant California native perennials, shrubs, bulbs and wildflower seeds. Shop thousands of beautiful plants and water-wise solutions for your home landscape and get the expert advice you’d expect from California’s native garden.

    Members-only

    Saturday, November 5, 8 a.m. until 11 a.m. Memberships (starting at $45 individual and $75 family) may be purchased at the sale. For information, contact our membership team at (909) 625-8767 ext 222.

    VETERANS DAY

    The annual Veterans Day observance in Memorial Park will be a week from Friday.  Again, from the City's website:

    Veterans Day Ceremony at Memorial Park (Nov 1, 2011)

    The City of Claremont and American Legion Post 78 proudly announce the annual Veterans Day Ceremony in Memorial Park (840 N. Indian Hill Blvd), on Friday, November 11 at 11 a.m. This ceremony honors veterans of all wars including living, deceased, killed in combat, prisoners of war (POW's), and missing in action (MIA's).

    The ceremony will include comments from members of American Legion Post 78, Mayor Pro Tem Larry Schroeder, and various community members. The ceremony will also feature Taps performed by the El Roble Marching Band.

    For more information about the City of Claremont's Veterans Day Ceremony, log onto the City website at www.ci.claremont.ca.us or call (909) 399-5490.

    Tuesday, September 7, 2010

    Water Wise

    Claremont City Manager Jeff Parker's weekly report last Thursday led with a blurb about a turf buyback program offering $3 for every square-foot of yard grass homeowners replace with drought-tolerant landscaping:

    TURF BUYBACK PROGRAM NOW AVAILABLE IN CLAREMONT!

    Golden State Water Company and Three Valleys Municipal Water District have teamed up to offer cash rebates to Claremont homeowners that remove turf and replace it with water-wise landscaping. The Residential Turf Removal Program rebates $3.00 per square foot for turf removed up to a maximum of $3,000 per residence. Details of the program and an application to participate can be found at:

    http://www.socalwatersmart.com/images/PDFs/mwd_rebate_form_turf_removal.pdf
    .

    The City is excited about this program because it should help the community meet its goal of reducing potable water consumed community-wide by 20% by 2012. City Council members have been pushing for a turf buyback program, noting that 70% of water used in Claremont is for outdoor uses and that turf is almost always the most water intensive plant in our yards.

    It's great to see the City leading the way when it comes to conservation issues, especially with sustainability having become a civic buzzword. That the City has encouraging residents to be aware of these sorts of environmental issues adds to City Hall's embarrassment over things like leaving the lights burning over unused sports fields.

    Claremont's municipal carbon footprint grew a little larger now that it's soccer fields at Padua Park are on line. A reader wrote to say someone forgot to switch off the field lights there last week:
    DATE: Sat, September 4, 2010 7:02:01 AM
    TO: Claremont Insider
    SUBJECT: Re: Claremont Insider

    Oh yeah, Friday night you could see the Padua park lights from space. You know the area in north claremont that isn't supposed to have any street lights. They wanted to keep that rural feeling. That is until "they" had yet another plan, uh huh I feel like I'm in the boonies...

    We heard separately from another reader that the Padua soccer lights were burning last Thursday night with no one on the fields. How fitting that the project that pushed the city budget millions of dollars into the red, a project touted for its "sustainability," continues to run up a bill for wasted dollars.

    We were thinking about those field lights when it occurred to us that the City has added over three acres of turf at Padua Park at precisely the same time they are asking residents to remove the grass in their yards. As City Manager Parker wrote, "City Council members have been pushing for a turf buyback program, noting that 70% of water used in Claremont is for outdoor uses, and turf is almost always the most water intensive plant in our yards."

    At around three acres (a conservative estimate), the fields at Padua Park amount to enough grass for 130 homes under the turf buyback program City Manager Parker touted.

    The City would argue that the turf planted in Padua Park is a drought-resistant, "water-wise" type, which may be perfectly true. However, several our readers have commented that ever since the park opened, the park's water usage has appeared pretty wasteful, including a substantial leak along one side of the westernmost soccer field. Even on the hottest of days, standing water apparently pooled in the turf there.

    We were curious and, nearly five months after the park's opening, we finally dispatched someone to take a look at the situation. There wasn't any standing water, but we did notice some repair work was underway in the spot where the months-old leak was supposed to have been:

    Click on Image to Enlarge


    Though the turf in problem area had been removed, it looked like the leak hadn't been fixed yet:



    Looking around the park, we found other evidence of the City's water management prowess:

    Watering Dirt


    La Cienega


    A River Runs Through It


    Mighty Dry Oak

    Monday, March 8, 2010

    City News

    WORKS IN PROGRESS

    Claremont City Manager Jeff Parker's weekly report for March 4 had this news about the ongoing sidewalk construction and upcoming water service interruptions:

    VILLAGE CONSTRUCTION AND WATER COMPANY SERVICE INTERRUPTIONS

    The Village Accessibility project continues to progress. The sidewalk on the north side of First Street, from the Post Office alley to Yale Avenue, was installed this past week. Beginning Monday March 8, the work will move to First Street, between Yale Avenue and Indian Hill Boulevard. Westbound First Street, from Yale Avenue to Indian Hill Boulevard, will be closed for approximately two (2) days while the work is being performed.

    Golden State Water will have the following service interruptions to update water mains, services, and fire hydrants:
    • Yale Avenue and portions of Second Street and Bonita, from First Street to Fourth Street, starting at 11:00 p.m. on Sunday, March 7, to 7:00 a.m. Monday, March 8.

    • Bonita Avenue, from Indian Hill to Harvard, starting Tuesday, March 9, at 11:00 p.m. to 7:00 a.m. Wednesday, March 10.

    • Arrow Highway, from Elder Drive to easterly City limit, Oakdale Drive and adjoining areas, beginning Tuesday, March 9, from 8:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. (This Golden State Water project is in preparation for the Arrow Highway Resurfacing Project.)
    All businesses and property owners are being contacted by the Water Company. The majority of the utility work in the Village, conducted by the Water and Gas companies, is taking place after the businesses are closed.


    HEALTH NEWS

    Parker's newsletter also had information about the annual Health and Wellness Expo on March 20:
    Health and Wellness Expo

    The City of Claremont Human Services Department and Pomona Valley Hospital are excited to announce a Health & Wellness Expo to be held on Saturday, March 20, from 10 a.m. – 2 p.m. at the Alexander Hughes Community Center in Claremont. The Expo will include a wide variety of local businesses and non-profit organizations featuring health and wellness programs and services available to the community. Included in the day’s activities will be:
    • Hughes Center Open House & Class Demonstrations – A variety of contract class demonstrations, including cooking, dance, art classes, judo and more.

    • Free Health Screenings - Audiology, 3-D Video Otoscope Inspection of the Ear Canal, Blood Pressure, Body Mass Index, Body Fat Analysis, Chair Massage.

    • Vendor Fair - Various non-profits and businesses displaying their health and wellness programs.

    • Entertainment by the Happy Crowd – Claremont’s very popular children’s entertainers, the Happy Crowd, will perform at 11 a.m. and 1 p.m.

    • $1 BBQ Lunch hosted by the Kiwanis Club – The Kiwanis Club of Claremont will be hosting a BBQ Lunch from 11:30 a.m. – 1 p.m. Presale lunch tickets can be purchased at the Alexander Hughes Center and the Joslyn Center.
    For more information, please call either the Alexander Hughes Center at (909) 399-5490 or the Joslyn Center at (909) 399-5488.


    IN JUST SPRING...

    The little lame ballonman will be whistling on April 4 when the City and the local Rotary Club will host their annual spring celebration:
    Spring Celebration

    The City of Claremont and the Rotary Club of Claremont will be hosting the annual Spring Celebration on Saturday, April 3 from 9 - 11 a.m. This FREE community event includes a petting zoo, magician, crafts, and more. The candy egg hunt for children 10 and under will begin at 10:30 a.m. This year, the Kiwanis Club will host a pancake breakfast from 7 - 10 a.m. for $4 per person. For more information, contact the Alexander Hughes Community Center at (909) 399-5490.


    CITY SEEKS 4TH OF JULY IDEAS

    If you know of some person or group you think should be honored in this year's 4th of July parade, the city wants your input. Also, the City invites our K-6 readers to submit their ideas for this year's 4th of July theme. Mr. Parker tells us that you don't have much time to put in your two cents worth:
    CLAREMONT 4TH OF JULY HONOREES & THEME CONTESTS

    Honorees: The 2010 Independence Day Committee is now accepting nominations for Grand Marshal, Honored Citizen, and Honored Community Group, to be recognized at the 4th of July Celebration. All honorees will be presented with certificates at the pre-parade reception and appear in the official parade in their own decorated vehicle.

    Theme Contest: All Claremont students in grades K-6 are invited to enter their ideas for the theme of this year’s 4th of July Celebration. Each theme submitted must be four words or less and have no more than 36 characters. Winners will be recognized at a pre-parade reception, ride in the parade, receive a special prize and firework tickets, as well as see their theme used throughout the event.


    Nominations for Honorees and Theme Contest entries are due Thursday, March 18 to the Alexander Hughes Community Center. Entry forms can be found on the 4th of July website at
    www.claremont4th.org.

    Monday, July 27, 2009

    Infrastructure Monday

    VERIZON DIGS CLAREMONT

    As you probably know, Verizon has been slowly upgrading its wiring in the area. The company is replacing the old copper wires with a new fiber optic system (FiOS), which promises to bring us faster Internet access and a television system to compete with the Time Warner cable franchise.

    A reader wrote in to complain about the disruption and shoddy road patching done by the Verizon work crews:

    DATE:Friday, July 24, 2009 7:27 AM
    SUBJECT: FIOS construction
    TO: Claremont Buzz

    Hi. Just wanted to let you know that FIOS construction in Claremont is horrific. Long story short, they spent 6 weeks on my block of 6 homes. Verizon went through 3 crews from Simmons Court to Athens Court which is a matter of a few homes and trust me, once you see these guys in your neighborhood you will understand why. The quality of work, the clean up, the misinformation given to us as residents is unbelievable. Long story short, I have contacted Verizon officials and Claremont officials trying to get some straight answers and the bottom line, I wish I had never gotten involved. Verizon is supposed to come into a neighborhood and leave it as if they were never there…come drive Fairmont, Athens and Simmons Courts all the way up to Scripps and look at the streets. (Athens has been given more attention because 3 of the 6 of us called and complained.) The patch we can live with. The fact that Verizon construction drove immediately through the black tar and left marks from one end of the neighborhood to the other and Claremont is ok with this shouldn’t surprise me but it does. Claremont tells me we are on slurry schedule for 2010 so until then, I guess I should just be grateful I have FIOS underground! WOW!! So…Claremont BEWARE! FIOS is coming to a neighborhood near you and when they are gone…you will know they were there and definitely not for the better. FIOS had to come in but give me a break, I don’t have a “road degree” but sure know a good paving job when I see one and there isn’t one to be seen in my neighborhood.

    WHAT WATER CRISIS?

    In other infrastructure related news, there was some sort of burst water pipe yesterday morning at College Ave. directly across from the affordable housing project site at 111 S. College Ave. The leak was on the east side of the street and was just north of the Pooch Park. The source was hidden by the chainlink fence and the landscaping, but you could see the water pour from under the fence wire and flow down College Ave. in a torrent. One young fellow tried surfing the stream on a boogie board.

    Work crews (presumably from Golden State Water Co.) got the leak under control by around 10am. Sorta makes you wish Golden State had reinvested some of those rate hikes from the last 10 years into infrastructure maintenance rather than stock dividends.

    Tuesday, June 23, 2009

    City Council Meeting Tonight

    The Claremont City Council meets tonight in the council chambers at 225 W. 2nd St. in the Claremont Village. You can watch all the action beginning at 6:30pm on the City's website.

    CLOSED SESSION

    The council will meet in a special closed session at 5:15pm to discuss the potential purchase of the water utility, currently provided by Golden State Water Co. Before anyone gets too excited, there doesn't seem to be any concrete action planned, though you never know what happens behind closed council doors.

    Here's the closed session agenda. The Daily Bulletin had an article on the subject. The article, by Wes Woods II, quoted several councilmembers, including Sam Pedroza:

    Councilman Sam Pedroza said the council expects to review several options, such as whether the city should take over its water provider or just continue to fight the water company's rising rates.

    Pedroza said he brought the item to the council's attention because residents have been asking him about the increased rates.

    In December, Claremont joined San Dimas, Apple Valley and Placentia in hopes of halting rising water rates charged by the water company.

    "We've been talking about it for many, many years," Pedroza said. "Because of the water situation we're in and the economy, it's never going to be cheaper than what it is right now. We need to do something."

    REGULAR SESSION

    The regular session commences at 6:30pm with a couple ceremonial matters: a farewell to Claremont Unified School District Superintendent David Cash and a recognition of the David and Margaret Youth & Family Auxiliary Group's 38th Anniversary.

    Tonight's regular session seems light, and the council may get out before 9:30 for a change. Here are a few items of interest:
    • A lot line adjustment for three parcels at 101 S. Mills Ave. This property is owned by the Claremont University Consortium. This appears to be the maintenance yard between 1st St. and the Metrolink tracks.

    • Institutional District parking standards. Staff is asking the council to affirm the direction the council has given regarding revisions to the parking standards for the areas in and around the Claremont Colleges. Staff wants to have the Municipal Code amendment and the necessary environmental review prepared by this fall.

    • A resolution in support of the League of California Cities mounting a legal challenge to the state's proposed money grab. We talked about this yesterday. The staff report says that Claremont could potentially lose $600,000 in transportation funds if the state borrows money from the Highway Users Tax Account, money set aside for local governments from the state's gasoline tax. The money is used for local street maintenance.

      As we noted yesterday, other area cities have already adopted the same type of resolution.

    • Senior apartment bonds. This is a request for the City to hold a hearing for the Claremont Villas under the federal Tax Equity and Financial Responsibility Act (TEFRA). The owner of the 154-unit senior housing complex, Claremont Senior Partners, LLP, wants to refinance and pay off its existing debt obligations in order to give the property 100% non-profit ownership.

      Claremont would bear no financial responsibility. The City simply has to hold the hearing for Claremont Senior Partners to be able to apply for the bonds. The City recently did the same thing for Western Christian Schools, and they have also held TEFRA hearings for Pilgrim Place and Claremont Manor.



    Friday, June 12, 2009

    More Water Rationing News

    Like the rest of us, you probably received a notice in the mail today from Golden State Water Company regarding a public meeting next Wednesday, June 17, at 6:30pm. The meeting will allow the water company to explain their proposed mandatory water rationing plan.

    You may want to pay attention because there are fines of $50 to $300 that can be imposed for violations, depending on which of the seven stages of water rationing we happen to be at. The conditions listed seem to track the city's proposed water conservation ordinance.

    The City of Claremont's website carried this notice, along with a link to the text of the mailing:

    Public Meeting on Staged Mandatory Water Rationing

    Golden State Water Company (GSWC) filed Advice Letter 1332-W requesting authority from the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) to institute a staged mandatory rationing plan (Plan). The proposed Plan would only go into effect when specific criteria, detailed in the Plan, are met. A Public meeting will be held on June 17, 2009 at Double Tree Hotel, Sequoia Room, 555 W. Foothill Boulevard, Claremont, CA, to explain the rate process and to receive public input.

    GSWC customers who would like to provide any other information or comments regarding this requested increase, should write to the CPUC at the address below.

    Written public comment by GSWC customers is very much desired by the CPUC and may be sent to the CPUC's Water Division at 505 Van Ness Avenue, San Francisco, CA 94102, 3rd Floor, Room 3102, or e-mailed to regulatoryaffairs@gswater.com. Please refer to Golden State Water Company's Advice Letter No. 1332-W in any communications.

    View GSWC Manadatory Conservation Notice (Adobe Acrobat, 35KB)

    The public is also invited to send written comments to the California Public Utilities Commission. The water company mailing gave this information:
    Written public comment by GSWC customers is very much desired by the CPUC and may be sent to the CPUC's Water Division at 505 Van Ness Avenue, San Francisco, CA 94102, 3rd Floor, Room 3102. Please refer to Golden State Water Company's Advice Letter No. 1332-W in any communications.

    GOLDEN STATE WATER CO. MEETING
    Wednesday, June 17, 6:30pm
    Double Tree Hotel
    555 W. Foohill Blvd.
    Claremont, CA 91711

    Sunday, May 31, 2009

    Flush with Pride

    Click to Enlarge
    With California in the midst of its third year of drought, water agencies have begun instituting water conservation measures. The search for ways of reducing water consumption is on, and the City of Claremont announced a toilet exchange program sponsored by Golden State Water Co. (see flyer at right) If you have an old toilet (3.8 gallons per flush), you can trade that for a new, high-efficiency model at no cost.

    The exchange takes place at Claremont High School on Saturday, June 27, starting at 8am. The event also helps support the Claremont High girls softball team. Here's the information listed on the City website:

    Free High-Efficiency Toilets for Golden State Water Customers

    Golden State Water Company will be distributing free, high-efficiency toilets at Claremont High School (1601 N. Indian Hill Boulevard) on Saturday, June 27, 2009, starting at 8:00 a.m. By participating, you are supporting Claremont High School Softball Boosters. Click on the link below for participation requirements and information on how to reserve a free high-efficiency toilet.

    Wednesday, February 4, 2009

    Water Rates Going Way Up Unless You Attend

    Just a reminder, tomorrow there will be two opportunities to provide comment to an administrative law judge from the California Public Utilities Commission.

    Two "public participation" hearings are scheduled at the Hughes Center in Claremont:

    Thursday, February 5, 2009, 2:00 p.m.
    Alexander Hughes Community Center
    1700 Danbury Road, Grove Room
    Claremont, California

    Thursday, February 5, 2009, 6:00 p.m.
    Alexander Hughes Community Center
    1700 Danbury Road, Grove Room
    Claremont, California

    See our Monday post for more information, copies of the notice, and links to the City website with the City's take on this whole deal. If there is one point to be made, apart from the fact that Golden State Water Company's rate request in excess of 35% is outrageous, it is that it is very unfair of the PUC to have allowed Golden State to "regionalize" our water rates and include us with portions of Golden State's business with which we have no nexus, such as Barstow, Calipatria, Orange County, San Dimas, and San Gabriel, Wrightwood and Morongo Valley.

    This "regionalization", by the way, was done about a decade ago with the acquiescence of then-City Manager Glenn Southard, we presume with the good advice of his strong right-hand, then-Assistant City Manager Bridget Healy. (pictured, left)

    Monday, February 2, 2009

    Coming Thursday: Water Rate Hike Hearings

    Click to Enlarge
    The California Public Utilities Commission will be holding a couple public hearing this Thursday, February 5th, at Claremont's Hughes Center. The City is encouraging residents to attend and to voice objections to the the planned rate hike being sought by our water provider, Golden State Water.

    The city's website includes a link to a list of talking points they feel are especially important. Here's the information the City has posted:
    California Public Utilities Commission Seeks Public Participation and Request for Public Comment

    The California Public Utility Commission (CPUC) will be holding two public hearings regarding Golden State Water Company's (GSWC) formal application for a rate increase. The hearings will be held in the Padua Room at the Alexander Hughes Center, located at 1700 Danbury Road, at 2 p.m. and 6 p.m. on Thursday, February 5, 2009.

    The City of Claremont believes that GSWC has not provided a compelling reason why an interim rate relief is merited, and the City, as a substantial ratepayer, deserves the benefit of a full Commission process before any rate increases are imposed.

    The CPUC is seeking public comment on this formal application by GSWC. As part of its decision-making process, the CPUC is interested in your comments on any aspect of the company's operation including proposed rates, service quality or any other issue of concern.

    Claremont residents are strongly encouraged to attend one of these hearings. The Public Participation Hearing provides the public an opportunity to provide comment on any portion of Golden State Water Company's Application before a CPUC Administrative Law Judge.

    Here is a list of some talking points to assist you when speaking to the CPUC:
    • The Proposed overall rate increase is more than 35% higher than current rates.

    • Overall rate increase is unreasonable in the current state of the economy, with people losing jobs, facing foreclosure and not being able to afford higher utility bills.

    • Wrightwood Pipeline being built in another town located far from Claremont: Because of regionalized rate structure, citizens of Claremont will subsidize pipeline project through their rates, but receive no benefit from it.

    • GSWC is not establishing the required connection between the cost of the proposed conservation measures and the benefit/savings to local communities. Citizens care deeply about conservation, but want to see conservation measures implemented properly and effectively.

    • Return on investment sought by GSWC is unreasonable in this economic climate. GSWC shouldn't be making a higher profit, when other business and citizens are merely trying to stay afloat.

    For a copy of the talking points, click on the link below.

    Claremont residents are also encouraged to immediately e-mail/write to the Public Utilities Commission to protest Golden State Water's interim rate increase:

    Email: public.advisor.la@cpuc.ca.gov

    Send correspondence to:
    CPUC's Public Advisor's Office
    320 West 4th Street, Suite 500
    Los Angeles, CA 90013

    Here's a link to the City of Claremont talking points

    Monday, December 8, 2008

    Golden State Water Comin' at Ya Again

    Unhappy with its prospects in the normal rate-setting process, Golden State Water Company has filed an Advice Letter with the California Public Utilities Commission for an immediate unjustified increase of almost $4.5 million on top of the some $95 million it already collects from its territory which includes Claremont.

    Notice of Interim Rate Increase by
    Golden State Water Company
    Region III Service Territory
    Advice Letter 1309-W

    A notice hit people's mailboxes Saturday afternoon and we here at the Insider have been inundated with an email about it ever since.

    But that's how it is with these things--mostly hushed silence. And that is fine with Golden State. The water company wants to make this whole rate-setting deal as opaque as possible. The notice does contain the occasional clause written in more or less simple declarative English: "...company's request to implement an interim rate increase for 2009", "...seeking to increase rates by $4,481,200 or 4.74% in 2009", "...the monthly bill would increase...", "would experience a monthly increase..."

    After the cheery news heading page two that "[w]ritten public comment by GSWC customers is very much desired by the CPUC...", we find that one has to be practically a water law attorney to even get started: "A protest objects to the advice letter in whole or in part and must set forth the specific grounds on which it is based..." and then goes on to list six acceptable grounds. See them on page two of the notice, elsewhere in this post. However, the first one seems straightforward enough: "(1) The utility did not properly serve or give notice of the advice letter."

    Our guess is that Golden State probably complied with the legal requirement for notice, whatever that may be and wherever that may be found. But who would know? Who among the thousands customers would know this?--those who received this notice more than two weeks after the filing date (November 18) and just two days before the 20-day protest period closes (by our count, close of business on Monday, December 8).

    And who among the Golden State customers can just dash off a weekend letter to the Public Utilities Commission protesting that "(2) [t]he relief requested in the advice letter would violate statute or Commission order, or is not authorized by statute or Commission order on which the utility relies"?

    And in case you thought, maybe, you could address that issue, be sure to note that "[a] protest shall provide citations or proofs where available to allow staff to properly consider the protest."

    To make the whole exercise even more obscure, there is no copy of Advice Letter 1309-W, and we spent the wee hours of Saturday night and most of the day Sunday looking. Not on the Golden State website. Search for it and you get this:

    Not on the CPUC website. We'll spare you the search process, but the only CPUC document mentioning Advice Letter 1309-W appears to be the Commission's daily calendar for November 19, memorializing receipt of the aforesaid advice letter the day before (and giving the only clue, if we read it right, of the filing date--it's buried quite far down in a long document).

    So how is the protesting customer supposed to protest and object to the advice letter in whole or in part and set forth the specific grounds on which it is based, without knowing what is contained in the advice letter?

    We may be forced to rely on the City of Claremont to carry our water--as it were--on this matter. Remember, the City has engaged BBK to work the problem of outlandish rate increase proposals by Golden State Water Company made to the Public Utilities Commission. Maybe this will come up at Tuesday's council meeting, though it's not on the agenda.

    Meanwhile, in case you want to dash off your own protest and have lost the notice, here is what Golden State sent that arrived over the weekend (as with all images, click on the image to enlarge):


    Thursday, October 16, 2008

    $35 Million Water Rate Increase

    They come around with the predictability of eclipses or the tides or the change of seasons. They are applications by the Golden State Water Company to the California Public Utilities Commission (PUC) for another RATE INCREASE. Since the water company is a regulated utility, all rate increases must be approved by the PUC.

    Last month the water company sent yellow notices to all of its customers advising of yet one more bite at the rate-payers' apple:

    NOTIFICATION OF APPLICATION FILING BY GOLDEN STATE WATER COMPANY FOR A RATE INCREASE
    REGION III SERVICE AREA
    REQUEST FOR PUBLIC COMMENTS
    APPLICATION NO. 08-07-010

    Down in the fifth paragraph, the water company advises us that the total request for Region III, which includes Claremont, is for $35,414,600, with the bulk of it, $30,035,900 coming as a 33% increase in 2010!

    Why Is This Man Smiling?


    This breathtaking increase request is quite in keeping with the modus operandi of Golden State in initially asking the PUC for the moon and then settling for a few scattered comets, asteroids, and pieces of space junk. Over the years, Golden State comes in with a highball request, the wheels of the PUC grind exceedingly slow and fine, and the Commission ultimately approves an increase in the neighborhood of half what was initially requested--still, gobs and gobs of money. Enough to keep President and CEO Floyd E. Wicks in those nice suits for a long time (see photo, right).

    This year the Claremont City Council approved $30,000 to pay lawyers at Best, Best and Krieger to represent the City as a participant in the rate increase application process. This process is a highly choreographed procedural minuet, and becoming a "participant" is the only way effectively to have a voice. [Reading the staff report referenced just above authored by that Candide of Claremont, Scott Carroll, would make a reader believe that the City's vaunted participation and protest single-handedly brought Golden State's water hikes to rein. The City participation was important, as it is a formal way to participate, but even in 1996, when the City was not a participant, the 56% increase request was slashed to 12%. As we recall--we could be wrong--the big deal that year was not the rate per se, but getting approval of a new rate structure with separate "meter" (fixed hookup charges), and "commodity" (water usage) rates. Anyway, post hoc ergo propter hoc, Scott.]

    All of which makes us wonder, whatever became of the fanciful idea of the City purchasing the water company? We haven't heard about it for a long, long time, and it is a remnant from the bad old days of Glenn Southard, giving you some idea of how long it has been floating around. Did the City come face to face with financial reality on this idea? This is how the world ends, not with a whim but with a banker.

    More on all of this as it unfolds in the community. For now, in case you lost yours, here is the notice sent last month--or perhaps it was August--by Golden State Water (click on images to enlarge:

    (If links below appear broken, try again later. The PUC appears not to have paid its electric bill.)
    (Links seem to be working again. Guess Arnie sold those short-term bonds)

    Also, if you are really a glutton for punishment of the worst sort, here is a link to the California Public Utilities Commission file on the July 1, 2008 Golden State Water Company rate increase.

    The 70-page rate increase application is here.

    The City's August 7 protest is here (4 pages).