Claremont Insider: Search results for trolley
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query trolley. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query trolley. Sort by date Show all posts

Thursday, April 23, 2009

Square Head, Round Hole

Whatever else you have to say about Claremont Trolley supporters, you cannot deny their persistence.

A reader wrote in to tell us about a Facebook event this afternoon from 12 noon to 2pm in the Claremont Village. The event is a Chamber of Commerce-sponsored rally to support the trolley, which went belly-up at the last City Council meeting.

As part of the event, you can follow it live on Twitter. Here's the tweeting party's description:

Join me, Joey Coombe, as I Twitter Live from the Claremont Trolley. This event approaches the issue of public funding for transportation related uses through new media and technology.

Follow at http://twitter.com/joeycoombe

[NOTE: This was actually a joke by Coombe. No real involvement form the Chamber of Commerce -ed.]

* * * * *

Yesterday's Courier had a letter from reader Rochelle Darrow, who wrote that she liked the trolley but thought the routing was sketchy:
The trolley was a good intention, but I for one was confounded with its route. If you were for instance visiting the theatre you would just drive there. Once in the village area everything is in walking distance. The trolley route served no purpose.

It would be wonderful if the trolley made a wider route, say north on Mills taking people to Vons. West on Baseline then south on Indian Hill stop at Trader Joes and proceed back down to the village.

The real problem wasn't just the route. Cost was the limiting factor. The trolley runs only three days a week. That really isn't a regular enough schedule to be considered a true transportion service. After all, who'd utilize a bus service that operated less than half of the time?

Why only three days? The trolley ran the schedule it did because the City couldn't afford to spend more than the $887,000 it did on the current level of service.

To run the trolley five days a week would have raised the cost to $1.27 million on its current route. And that's for one trolley that takes 15 minutes to circumnavigate it's little 1.5 mile circuit of the Claremont Village. If you were to add on stops at the Claremont Colleges and trips up to Foothill and Base Line Rd., you're talking about potentially quadrupling the time it takes one trolley to complete a circuit. With only one trolley that could mean up to an hour wait - only 12 circuits in the trolley's 12-hour day on its three days of operation.

To extend the route and keep the stops at the same 15-minute level of service, you'd have to add two or three trolleys, depending on how much you lengthened the route. And to really make the trolley a functional transportation service, you'd have to run it at least five days - and probably seven - a week. You're not only talking about multiplying the $887,000 cost by adding more trolleys and their drivers, you'd also be adding at least two more days of service, not to mention the expense of building the new stops and the added cost of fueling, insuring and maintaining the extra trolleys.

The City bought all it could afford with the money it had and couldn't come close to spending millions more to turn the trolley into a true transportation service. City staff has said as much, maintaining that the trolley was not a transportation service but an economic engine designed to bring more customers to the Village - a mission it failed miserably at.

* * * * *

David Allen was at the April 14 City Council meeting when the council voted 3-2 to pull the plug on the trolley. Allen neatly summed up the non-Trolley boosters' take:
And if you happen to gaze in the trolley's windows as it passes by, you rarely see anyone inside except the poor driver. It's like a - gaaaahh! - ghost trolley.

Condemned to endlessly circuit the Village, making a series of hard left turns, the drivers are on a voyage of the damned, the Claremont equivalent of the Flying Dutchman.

At last, city leaders voted this week to lift the curse, free the drivers and allow the trolley to head into the sunset.

Allen also quoted a clearly out-of-touch Sam Pedroza, who typically did not get it, sounding a lot like former Councilmember Sandy Baldonado.

You might recall when Baldonaldo, along with Pedroza and the rest of the Claremont 400, tried to foist a $48 million assessment district on Claremonters in 2006. After property owners resoundingly rejected the assessment, Baldonado said, "...it's not the city that I know and love."

Pedroza, as quoted by David Allen, displayed a similar tin ear, bringing up another failed Claremont transportation idea:
Councilman Sam Pedroza, however, said another trait of Claremonters is to rush to condemn new ideas. He brought up the traffic circle, which was torn out within weeks of its installation in 1999 due to jeering.

It's simply stunning that Pedroza can reinterpret history so freely. The traffic circle he spoke of, at Indian Hill and Bonita Ave., failed not because of any "jeering," as Pedroza calls it. It failed because it was a potentially good idea shoehorned into much too small of a space to handle the volume of traffic safely. The radius of the circle had to be fitted into the corners marked by the existing sidewalks, which left too tight a space for the number of cars passing through. All it did cause more delays than the existing traffic signal because of driver confusion.

These circles can work if they're in the right places and if they're sufficiently big enough to allow the traffic to flow smoothly - they're everywhere in Europe, and in a number of places here in Southern California - but the Claremont circle, much like the trolley, was jammed into the wrong place without any forethought and with very predictable results.

But, in Pedroza's mind, it's much easier to blame public rather than rationally assess the facts at hand.

Friday, January 25, 2008

Transportation News


Lot's of train news in today's Daily Bulletin:


GOLD LINE ON HOLD

Leading things off, it looks like the Gold Line is on hold. According to a Bulletin article, the Metropolitan Transportation Authority board left the Gold Line project off a list of critical projects.

The Gold Line did make a list of secondary projects, but without being on the A-list, the project cannot qualify for matching federal funds. So, the project is effectively on hold, the article said:

The 13-member Metropolitan Transportation Authority board effectively delayed construction of the $1.4 billion project until at least the end of 2009, subject to final approval of the regional funding list by mid-year.

Supporters of the extension had hoped to break ground before year's end, with initial service to Azusa and Glendora late in 2009, said authority CEO Habib Balian.

"But all this will add time to the project, causing a six-month to a year delay," said Balian. "We won't be able to get started when we wanted to."

TROLLEY PROJECT ROLLS FORWARD

The Bulletin also had a couple articles on the Claremont Off Track Trolley, for which the Claremont City Council Tuesday approved going forward with a bid process.

Will Bigham had a short article on the issue.

And David Allen had a column covering the council meeting Tuesday night. The most interesting bit from Allen's piece was the fact that he was able to attend two city council meetings that night, visiting Montclair as well as Claremont.

Allen wrote that the Montclair council meeting, which started at 7pm, lasted only 16 minutes, giving him plenty of time to make the trolley discussion in Claremont, an amazing stat given that for Claremont's council, Tuesday's ceremonial matters alone at the start of meeting must have taken over 16 minutes.

Besides mentioning the cost (originally pegged at $886,878 over three years, now up to $1,290,596), Allen brought up an objection we've heard from readers: Do we really need a trolley to cover a six-square block area?

Claremont Mayor Peter Yao and Mayor Pro Tem Ellen Taylor both talked about the replica trolley in Portland, OR, which they claimed was great and partly responsible for Portland's downtown renaissance. Of course, the comparison is a false one.

Claremont's trolley is really a small bus and will run 12.5 hours a day, three days a week on a 1.5 mile, 15-minute loop and carry a projected 15 passengers per hour. Portland's trolley runs on a light-rail line and is part of a large, urban transit system integrated with several light-rail lines and a bus system linking the downtown area to the airport and to suburbs, carrying thousands of people a day.

Allen seemed to find some of the same false notes in the comparison:
Mayor Peter Yao and Vice Mayor Ellen Taylor were the most enthusiastic. Yao touted Portland, Ore., with its popular trolley [pictured right] and rising property values along the line as a comparison.

That's a stretch, and I say that as someone tempted to pack up and move to Portland after a single visit. That is, if its famously overcast skies didn't promise 10 months a year of seasonal affective disorder.

Portland's a big city, and its trolley system is wide-ranging - 7.2 miles - and runs on real tracks.

One of our readers also wrote in with an opinion on the trolley business:

This sounds like another ill-fated idea like the roundabout. It is also indicative of the "there is nothing too good for Claremont, we're #5 and we deserve the best no matter what the cost" mentality that has re-surfaced in an even more virulent form with this council. It would be a riot to see a graphic that has a trolley, perhaps with some of the Claremont 400 sticking out of it, going around a roundabout. Rather like a dog chasing its tale to mix a metaphor. If this is such a great idea, why aren't some of the businesses ponying up some funds for it? Well, because they have suckered the city to do it for them and take all the risk.

In the meantime, we need a police station, infrastructure maintenance, and a host of other things that cities are obligated to provide for their citizens, not flights of fancy and questionable expenditures on the taxpayers dime. When this city should be tightening its belt it is indulging in the excessive spending that has led many a city into financial ruin.

I hope some people go to the budget hearings and express this view.

If Taylor and Yao (Tweedledee and Tweedledummer) are inured to the warnings perhaps Elderkin and Pedroza are still open to behaving like the proverbial ants instead of the grasshopper.


One last bit concerning the trolley. It occurred to us that the city may be on questionable grounds using state and county transit funds for the trolley project. The trolley, after all, isn't really a transit project. As presented by Claremont Community Services Director Scott Carroll and the Off Track Trolley Citizen's Committee (Claremonster Judy Wright) the trolley is supposed to benefit businesses, not drivers, commuters, bikers, or pedestrians.

By the city's own admission, the trolley is an economic development project, designed to encourage shopping in Claremont. The primary target of the trolley, according to the staff report, are people who would be likely to spend more in town. That's why the colleges are not included in the pilot project. Students don't spend as much money - Carroll said as much on the video from the Tuesday meeting.

In case we've forgotten, Claremont got into hot water with the U.S. Department of Transportation a couple years ago for using DOT grant money for the Village Expansion parking structure. Former City Manager Glenn Southard and his assistant Jim Lewis had falsely pitched the structure as transit center parking when in fact it was for Village Expansion shoppers.

Those who forget history, etc....

Thursday, September 11, 2008

Trolley Unveiled

The City of Claremont's website informs us that the new downtown "trackless trolley" (bureaucratese for "mini-bus that has been dolled up to look like a cable car"). The city's note says:

There will be four bus stops on the route, which will be located at the Depot on First, the Metrolink parking lot, Bonita at Yale, and Oberlin Avenue across from the public plaza, completing a 1.5 mile loop.

Final preparations are being made such as training the drivers on the trolley, finishing the trolley stops, and the final touches to the trolley.

The Trolley will be on display at the following community events: Village Wine Walk on September 12 in front of City Hall, at the annual Village Venture on October 25th next to the City's booth on Second Street, and the trolley will also be featured in the parade at the Los Angeles County Fair on "Claremont Day," September 18.

The Inaugural Ride will take place at 10 a.m. on Thursday, October 30. There will be a short ceremony, light refreshments and residents will have a chance to be one of the first to ride the trolley before it officially begins service at 11a.m. that same day.

If you have any questions about the trolley program please contact the Community Services Department at (909)399-5431.

Yesterday's Claremont Courier also had an article about the trolley debut (the article isn't available online). The Courier reports Claremont has retained the Pomona Valley Transit Authority to operate the trolley, which will run through a three-year pilot program.

The Courier also reported that the trolley will cost a projected $1,290,596 for the three years. This is a substantial increase over the $887,000 the city had promised back in January. Where does the extra $400,000 go? Apparently, the original figure didn't include the costs of building bus stops and marketing. And gas is more expensive now.

In any case, using the original city estimate of 15 riders per hour, 12.5 hours per day, three day per week, we get 87,750 riders for the three year pilot program or about $14.71 per rider, a nearly 50% increase in the estimated cost for the three-year trial. At that price, the trolley out to be gold-plated.

Don't worry, though. As the city gleefully points out, its not OUR money! The project funded by state transportation fund money, so we can throw it away whatever way we want. Of course, if Sacramento pols pull transportation bond funds to balance the state budget, Claremonters may end up getting stuck a good chunk with the trolley bill. (But we don't want to talk about that.)

The Courier reported on some of the trolley's amenities:
The new vehicle has red paint, wooden seats and a manual bell ringer to replicate more authentic-looking track trolleys operating in cities like San Francisco and Portland. It will be ADA compliant and run on clean-burning gasoline.

We're not sure what differentiates "clean-burning" gasoline from other types, but we do suspect that Claremont's trolley, which covers and area of about six downtown blocks, probably won't help Claremont replicate San Francisco or Portland any more than the Paris Hotel in Las Vegas replicates the real French capital. But a person can dream.

Friday, October 31, 2008

Transportation Friday

We've got more transportation news today, beginning with the Claremont Trolley, which began service yesterday. The free, trackless trolley will run three days per week, Thursdays through Saturdays, from 11am to 11pm and will now cost an estimated $1,290,596 for the three-year trial, up from the original estimate of $887,000. The city is estimating the trolley will average 15 riders per hour.

The trolley is being paid for with money Claremont receives from state transportation bond money, even though it has been described by city officials as an economic development project rather than as a transportation project (it supposedly encourages shoppers in different areas of the Claremont Village and Village Expansion).

The Daily Bulletin's Wes Woods II covered the trolley unveiling:

CLAREMONT - City officials and residents on Thursday celebrated the Claremont Village Trolley with a barbershop quartet, christening and free cake and punch.

"I think having a trolley will make the downtown attractive" to those who live outside Claremont, said resident Ping Chang, 42, who rode the trolley for the first time with her 4-year-old daughter, Tiffany.

For Community Services Director Scott Carrol, this is exactly what he believes will happen, as the trolley "promotes economic development in the Village," he said.

To welcome the start of the free trolley service on Thursday morning, Mayor Ellen Taylor spoke to city officials and residents at the Claremont Depot on First Street.

The event was the culmination of events that started with the City Council's approval in January of using transportation money to fund the new service for three years.

The Bulletin's David Allen also had a column on the trolley. Allen seemed skeptical of the project's success, and the column's headline is "Not All Aboard 'Trolley.'" Allen also managed to fit quotes from a current and a former Claremont mayor into the piece:

....Mayor Taylor is already a fan.

"It's very cute," Taylor said. "Very Claremont."

And also very Victoria Gardens, I told her.[SNOB ALERT - CI ed.]

"Do they have one?" Taylor asked. "I never go there."

The "trolley" was about to depart for its third trip. I climbed aboard. It has arched windows, wooden slat seats and straps for anyone who stands. But it also has tires and a bus driver.

A few passersby gave us curious looks. At Bonita and Yale, two women jumped up and down and took photos. Outside the Back Abbey pub on Oberlin, an employee watched quizzically before giving us a wave.

I rarely walk along First, so it was educational to learn the Peyton Grey clothing store is gone. With Chloe & Hunter, that's two recent closures in the Village Square. Oh, if only they could have hung on until the "trolley" started!

Moments later the vehicle was back at the depot, disgorging a columnist. I say, disgorging a columnist.

Former mayor Karen Rosenthal, who rode the faux trolley earlier, was lingering.

"I don't know who's going to ride it," Rosenthal admitted. "Maybe if you park in the Metrolink lot. But if you park in the Village, you could walk three blocks to the trolley, or you could walk three blocks to where you want to be.

"The ones who'll ride it," she added conspiratorially, "are the people who really need to be walking."

Queen Ellen (left) also received a mention in LA Times writer Steve Hymon's Bottleneck Blog. Hymon caught Taylor's opinion piece against LA County's Measure R, the proposed half-cent sales tax increase that would fund transportation projects. Hymon spoke with Her Highness:
I also spoke to Claremont Mayor Ellen Taylor earlier today. She recently wrote a scathing opinion piece against Measure R that ran in the papers in the San Gabriel Valley. She doesn't believe the Gold Line Foothill Extension receives enough funds in the spending plan to get it to Claremont and Montclair -- the plan guarantees it $735 million -- and, equally important, she doesn't believe the money that the Gold Line is promised would arrive in any kind of timely fashion.

I posed this traffic question to her: What's it like in the Valley these days? Her answer:
It's miserable. I’ve lived in Claremont for 30 years and traffic has gotten much worse -- to the point that we don’t go into L.A. anymore. That’s not good for me. I like a full life where you experience stuff. We’ll go to a concert on Sunday afternoon [in Los Angeles] rather than Saturday night because it’s easier to get in and out...

We’re like the bologna in the bread here. And they keep building. You take the 210 east and all you see is roofs and they’re building them without building the infrastructure.
That's a fascinating quote. Why? In early 2007, Times columnist Steve Lopez wrote a piece about how bad Westside traffic is, with quotes from one resident saying they too no longer tried to attend cultural events in downtown L.A. (The Lopez column led to the creation of the Bottleneck Blog). Taylor is essentially saying the same thing, but from the other side of Los Angeles County.



Tuesday, January 27, 2009

City Council Meets Tonight - More Trolley Folly

The Claremont City Council meets again today for another of their secret, closed session meetings, beginning at 4:30pm at City Hall.

According to the closed session agenda, there are two topics on the Council's plate:

  • A report on labor negotiations from City Manager Jeff Parker, Assistant City Manager Tony Ramos, and City Personnel Manager Shawna Urban.


  • A report on ongoing litigation: L.A. County Civil Court case #BS 117971, Protect Our Neighborhoods v. City of Claremont.

The Council will convene in its regular session at 6:30pm in the Council Chambers at 225 W. 2nd St. The regular session agenda's fairly light, but we did note a few items of interest:
  • The Council will consider doing away with the deferred compensation option for Councilmembers. Councilmembers are currently eligible for city health benefits. If they do not use those benefits, they can take that money ($914 per month) and put it into a deferred compensation account that's pretty much the same as a 401(k). It amounts to $10,968 a year, or nearly $44,000 for a four-year council term.

    The city will keep the health benefits option for Councilmembers who choose to take it. Peter Yao is the only person receiving the city-paid healthcare. The only person among the five councilmembers taking the deferred comp is Mayor Ellen Taylor, who certainly does not need the money.


  • Johnson's Pasture is back in the news. You might recall that extra $1 million the City had to pay out of its General Fund reserve because some incorrect wording in the deed resulted in the state pulling a million-dollar grant. Now, the Council is going to consider floating additional bonds to reimburse itself the reserve money they had to spend.

    The Council has the discretion to issue more bonds if they choose, but we question the wisdom of doing so at this time. The money's already been paid out. Financing that $1 million just adds the expense of interest that will have to be paid out on the bonds, so we'd really just be penalizing future generations for the staff's mistake.

    Also, according to the staff report for this item, the interest the city would have to pay would be 1.06% higher than for the bonds they originally issued. This is because the market for California municipal bonds has declined greatly in the past year.

    All in all, not a good idea. It's a bit like refinancing your home's equity. It's just going to end up costing you more in financing charges in the end. The fact that staff made no recommendation in their report indicates no one on that end thinks this sort of unnecessary refinancing makes for good policy.

    Whose idea was it, anyway?


  • The Council will also be asked to donate the use of the Claremont Trolley for a March 22nd fundraiser for the Claremont Community Foundation.

    One hardly knows where to start here. The trolley, which you can see making its slow, lonely circuit through the Claremont Village Thursdays through Saturdays, was a waste of $1.2 million that nearly anyone with a brain said would be a failure. (That is, everyone except former mayor Judy Wright and friends, who deemed this project essential to the welfare of our downtown businesses.)

    The person making the request for this private use of the publicly-funded trolley is none other than Judy Wright herself, through the Claremont Community Foundation. So, the Council will of course acquiesce to Judy's wishes and will give the trolley over to her for a day. Under Judy's proposal, the Trolley will be used in two two-hour Claremont Heritage-led tours of historic sites throughout the city.

    In a way it makes sense, repackaging the trolley from a transportation conveyance to a sightseeing one. The money raised would go a charity, and it would probably be a lot of fun. However, there's one problem: the trolley is funded by public transportation grants. The city was verging on fraud in the first place by using those funds for what they called an economic development project (the trolley was supposed to help create more foot traffic for downtown businesses).

    Now they're going even further and removing any pretense of a transportation-related mission for the poor trolley. Simply put, the City and Judy are taking public funds from outside agencies and shifting them to a private use. No matter how well-intended the cause, this sort of transfer of public money is wrong ethically because it puts the city in the position of choosing between good causes: you get the use of the resource, you don't. Also, it may wrong before the law as well because certain transporation grants specify that the money must have strictly public uses. That's why you don't see LA County MTA buses being used for things like American Cancer Society fundraisers, even if the buses are surplus ones sitting in a maintenance yard.

    The staff report also notes that the city has no policy for lending out the trolley for such an event. Does this mean that any group - the Girl Scouts, say - could request the use of the trolley on one of its off days? The Insider is planning a group outing to Disneyland. Can we take the trolley for a spin?

    The staff seems to see the lack of a policy as a clear problem. They pretty much say in their recommendation that the Council should approve this use before they set a policy in place for trolley use by outside groups.

    You can easily see why California is in a $41 billion hole. Imagine Claremont's and Judy's follies repeated across the state on every type of grant. Money intended for one use ends up funneled into other, unrelated things. It amounts to the worst sort of fraud. The City really ought to just pull the plug on the trolley and either give the transportation grant money back or use it for what it was intended: fixing potholes and repaving streets.

BELOW: Claremont Community Foundation
Executive Director Nickie Cleaves
asks the
Claremont City Council if her friend Judy can have the keys to the trolley.


(Click to Enlarge)

Monday, December 8, 2008

A Streetcar Named Desire

Whoever you are,
I have always depended on the kindness of strangers


The Claremont Trolley came to our attention a couple of times this past week. The first time was a brief piece on the back page of the Courier and with apologies, we will quote it in full:

TROLLEY NEWS

Not to nitpick, but a Claremont resident recently informed us of something relating to Trolley courtesy.

It appears Trolley-riders often "pull the cord" to alert the driver they would like to exit at the next stop. this action apparently causes the ringing of a very loud bell. After a bit of investigation, it has been learned that the Trolley driver will make all 4 stops, whether the bell is rung or not.
From our experience riding the trolley in question, that's what the sign says to do: pull the cord. Our feeling is, if they didn't want to have that element of trolley-realism, to give the rider the full trolley-experience, they wouldn't have the cord. What is unquestionably lame about the Claremont Trolley is that you can't just pull the cord to be let off anywhere it stops anyway, like the San Francisco cable cars. Now that would be neat, and might increase ridership.

Ridership needs increasing, and that brings us to our second interesting fact about the Trolley: it is a City Staff transportation benefit even more than a public transportation benefit; another example of the kindness of strangers to City Staff.

According to our very reliable source, City Community Services Director Scott Carroll was seen hanging from the strap last Friday noon, and getting off at the "Walters" stop. He was wearing his spiffy white slacks and a dark blue City shirt of celebrating some City administration or another. It struck us a little funny that he of all people should be riding the otherwise empty coach. Probably he is trying to get the ridership numbers up. Since his department operates the Trolley, we are sure the driver dutifully logged one rider from (we assume) the distant regions of the Metrolink lot to Bonita at Yale.

By the way, don't under any circumstances plan on getting off the Trolley at the Metrolink lot at night. The night ride is a creepy enough ride anyway, empty and hollow as the carriage always is, with it's shiny wooden benches and slats that show you the floor almost everywhere. But that far-corner parking lot stop is downright scary. One anemic light barely illuminates the area. There is a bike rack, and one of those mysterious metal boxes that seem to populate public parking lots everywhere. But the cement disappears rather too close into shadowy and overgrown trees right next to the similarly-shadowy and overgrown shrubs along the track. You know there is no humanity between you and the dark and cold steel buildings of the college maintenance yard. Except. You do know for certain that if there were a criminal in Claremont, and you know it would be a "he" and he would be big and burly and rough and merciless, well, that criminal would be hiding out in those very nearby shadowy shrubs. And you'd be left way out there by your lone self as the Trolley leaned away from the left turn onto First Street and headed towards the safety of the town.

And when the criminal without mercy revealed himself to you, all you could say would be, "Whoever you are, I have always depended on the kindness of strangers."

Tuesday, April 14, 2009

Tonight's City Council

The Claremont City Council meets tonight at 6:30pm in the council chambers at 225 W. 2nd St. in the Claremont Village. If you can't make the meeting but absolutely have to watch it, you can see the live streaming video here.

For a change, there's no special closed session tonight, just the regular public meeting. Here's the agenda.


CEREMONIAL MATTERS

The meeting kicks off with the introduction of two new Claremont police officers, Issac Reyes and Michael Snyder. Best of luck to CPD's latest additions.

The council will also recognize Jennifer Maglio, wife of former city council candidate Mike Maglio, for founding an organization for families with special needs children. Ms. Maglio's group is called "Thriving Families."

There are a number of items on the rest of the agenda, including the proposed inclusion of the city of Pasadena on the Foothill Transit Joint Powers Authority and the subdivision of a 3.16-acre parcel at 3232 Padua Ave. into three lots by a real estate investment group called Padua Estates, LLC.

The council will also consider helping Pilgrim Place qualify for something called TEFRA financing in the amount of $30 million. This is a tax-exempt financing mechanism available through the California Municipal Financing Authority (CMFA). The city staff report says there's no cost to the city and the CMFA debt, in the form of bonds, will be the sole responsibility of Pilgrim Place, according to the staff report.

You can review all of the agenda materials for tonight's meeting here (click on 2009, then find the link that says "09-04-14 Regular").

We pulled a couple of tonight's agenda items that caught our eye:


PR, CPD STYLE


Claremont staff reports too often slide into maddening self-promotion as department managers spin PR gold out of the flimsiest informational straw. The annual Claremont Police Department report is no exception.

(Welcome to Claremont, Officers Reyes and Snyder, hope you brought your waders with you. You didn't know CPD stood for Clearly Piled Deep.)

This year's CPD annual report, like every such document we've seen, employs a couple bureaucratic tricks to put a nice shine on the CPD image. One thing the department did differently this year, because of increases in traffic accidents and property crimes, was to expand its annual comparison of data from a year-over-year basis to a 13-year period. This takes us all the way back to the last big recession of the early 1990's, when crime was much higher.

No real reason is given for the change in the report's time horizon. CPD Chief Paul Cooper no doubt found it better to go back far enough to bury the bad news that property crimes were up 10% in 2008 and accidents increased 9%.

So, CPD trots out the good news that although traffic collisions in 2008 increased by 9% over the previous year, "they are still below average for three, five, and ten year periods." Technically, though, the accident rate has probably has nothing to do with anything the police department has done. There's really little they can do to reduce traffic collisions, other than perhaps having the occasional DUI checkpoints. Most crashes happen randomly; that's why they're called accidents.

If anything, Claremont's 9% increase in collisions last year was anomalous. In the U.S., as a whole, the auto accident rate declined in 2008, mostly because people are driving less. This is partly because more people are out work, and also because of last year's spike in gas prices. We found this tidbit from May, 2008, on the Wall Street Journal's website:

Bob Hartwig, president of the Insurance Information Institute, an industry trade group, said that, through the fourth quarter of 2007, he has seen no evidence that rising gasoline prices has made much of a change in driver habits. But the breaking of the $4 price barrier for a gallon of gasoline may be the final straw for drivers who have put up with steady increases, and could make a difference for insurer accident costs beginning in the second quarter.

He said a similar situation occurred in the 1970s, when oil embargoes cut supplies and raised prices.

Hartwig said data indicated “a very sharp drop” in auto accident frequency during the oil embargos, “but as soon as gas became available and prices fell, people rapidly began to drive again, and frequency moved back to pre-embargo levels,” he said. “Conventional wisdom would indicate that there should be a drop in frequency,” as long as gasoline prices stay above drivers’ comfort level.

So, CPD, no need to take the blame for a rising collision rate, just as there's not much call to take credit for a drop. It's out of your hands.

Claremont did see a 36% drop in violent crimes (rape, homicide, assault, robbery), according to the CPD report, but the city typically doesn't see many of those types of crimes in the first place, so any drop can result in a large percentage decline. For instance, there were no homicides in 2007 or 2008, and assaults dropped from 35 to 30 in that same period.

On the other hand, property crimes (thefts, burglaries, auto thefts, and arson) increased 10% from 2007. According to CPD's stats, property crimes increased from 985 to 1082, with the biggest jump coming in burglaries, which went up from 269 to 337.

Interestingly, Chief Cooper's message at the beginning of the report says that most of the increase in property crimes came at the Claremont Colleges. According to Chief Cooper, property crimes in Claremont's residential and business areas declined 2%, while it increased 67% at the 5C campuses. Keep a better eye on your stuff, kids!

You can read the entire report below (click on the little box in the upper right corner to enlarge to full screen):
4-14-09 CPD Annual Rpt



ROLL ON, TROLLEY, ROLL ON

The council is also being asked by city staff to continue the Claremont Trolley's three-year "economic development" mission because that's been sooooooo successful, as we can see by all the shuttered downtown businesses with for lease signs adorning the storefront windows.

The trolley's been a half-hearted venture from the beginning. It only runs three days a week (Thursday through Saturday), from 11am to 11pm, because the cost of running it five days would have been too high - $1.29 million for three years versus the current $887,000 estimate. And, the 15 minute cycle time it takes to go the few square blocks of the Village makes it much quicker to simply walk, which most people figure out after one ride.
Click to Enlarge
Consequently, we figure one might reasonably expect to see a drop in ridership from when the trolley first entered service to now, and that's precisely what the staff report shows (see table at right). The numbers were highest during the first month of operation (12.3 riders per hour) and have dropped to under seven riders per hour in March.

The trolley's ridership numbers don't lie. The original report for the trolley said that it would need to average 15 riders an hour to be viable. We figured that averaged out to over $10 per rider over the three-year trial period. A pretty expensive ride, yes, but not nearly as expensive as the $23.25 it's costing now at 6.8 riders an hour.

In the staff report, Community Service Director Scott Carroll (he of the Wilderness Park razing) speculates that the drop in ridership can be attributed to such factors as colder winter weather, shorter daylight hours, and the absence of events in the Village. "Silly notion" isn't mentioned as a contributing factor.

Staff is asking the council to adopt Option A of Carroll's report. That option (shown at left) calls for the council to continue the trolley as is and to form an ad hoc committee to study some alternatives that might include running the trolley up to Claremont High School or the Old Schoolhouse at Indian Hill and Foothill Blvds. The committee would come back with recommendations to the council at the May 12 meeting.

One option the committee might consider, and we're willing to offer this up for free courtesy of the Insider, is to scrap the trolley entirely and hire a limo service. We checked and found that American Limo in Los Angeles will charge between $65 and $68 an hour (depending on the day of the week) for an eight-person Lincoln. Eight would be more riders than the trolley has averaged per hour the last couple months.

At a little over $8 an hour per person, that's nearly a third of what the trolley's currently costing us. We could easily brand the limos with magnetic City of Claremont decals. This would also free up the trolley for more communitarian missions. The mind reels at the possibilities: Oak Park Cemetery hearse; library bookmobile; Human Services catering truck (could be packaged as Meals On Wheels); could be leased to local hospitals for convenient patient dumping; rolling affordable housing - with bunks, sleeps 24!

Perusing all of these trolley tables and figures, it occurred to us that over its short existence, the trolley has performed significantly worse than the Dow Jones Industrial Average, with ridership dropping about the same percentage as the Dow, but in five months instead of 10. Don't believe us? Check out this handy graphic from the Insider Institute of Finance:

Click to Enlarge

Thursday, March 26, 2009

Trolley Mail

Earlier this week we received a note from a reader with an observation about the Downtown Claremont Trolley. The reader saw the trolley on a run outside of it's usual environs:

DATE: Monday, March 23, 2009 10:46 PM
SUBJECT
: Claremont Trolley
TO: Claremont Buzz

Speaking of the Claremont Trolley.

On Sunday March 22, I noticed that the Trolley Folly went on a whimsy run, up Padua Ave. past the under-construction sports park, on up to the 4-way-on-demand stop light signal, at 1:07PM, then up Mt. Baldy Road, past Fergus Falls, presumably to the gravel turn-around at the San Antonio Dam, as it shortly returned down Mt. Baldy Road. It turned into Flat River and back out, and on down to Padua Ave., then north on Padua Ave. up past the Theater, then down Via Padova past the sharp double curves, and on down to Mt. Baldy Road, and then to the Mills 4-way stop signs, at 1:21PM, and then down Mills. I was not close enough, from my view point, to see if any passengers were inside.

We checked and discovered that what the reader witnessed was a Claremont Community Foundation event that we wrote about a couple months ago. This was the City loaning this public resource out to a private organization for a charity fundraiser, one of many CCF Party Parade events.

The CCF website said this about the Trolley Folly before the March 21st event slipped into the past (click on image adjacent to text):
With former Claremont Mayor and Author Judy Wright.

Ride the new Claremont Trolley as we travel from the Metrolink Parking Lot to Oak Park Cemetery and Russian Village, and then on to Padua Hills Theater, the Wilderness Park, and Webb School.

The tour of our vertical city will include residential neighborhoods in context including architecture by Gordon Kaufmann, Helen Wren, Paul Williams, Cliff May, Alan Taylor, Konstanty Stys, and Robert Orr. Architectural examples from Myron Hunt, Gordon Kaufmann, and Edward Durrell Stone, among others, as well as landscape architecture by Edward Huntsman Trout, Thomas Church, and Ralph Cornell, will be components of The Claremont Colleges. In the Village we will see and talk about what makes a downtown a downtown - the architecture, the people, the restaurants, the shops, the services, etc. The tour will take approximately two hours.
9:30 a.m. - Noon
or
12:30 - 3 p.m.

With light refreshments from Noon until 1 p.m.

$35 per person
Capacity: 20 guests per tour

Hosts:
Judy Wright
Kristin and Steve Hagstrom
Vicke Selk

Sponsored by the City of Claremont

The CCF's website said that both sessions, morning and afternoon, were sold out, so the Trolley was likely as full as you're ever going to see it. At 20 guests per session it was running at about 2,000 percent of its usually usage. Maybe we could convince the CCF to take over the lease.

Sunday, March 15, 2009

A Reader Writes - Transportation Funds

We received this bit of mail regarding Friday's post about the hedgehog and the fox The reader noted that rather than waste transportation funds on the useless and relatively unused Claremont Trolley, we could have found some real, though less glamorous, transportation needs on which to spend the money.

Or, we could have (gasp!) given the money back so it could be used by some community with transportation greater needs, assuming that the sort of money swaps that new Claremont Councilmember Larry Schroeder proposed during the campaign season aren't permitted.

Here's what our reader had to say:

DATE: Friday, March 13, 2009 2:38 PM
SUBJECT: Hedgehog/Fox
TO: Claremont Buzz

Responding to your hedgehog/fox article, it's worth noting that besides a trolley, there are in fact other transportation unmet needs in Claremont. So, not only is it not a question of trolley vs. $ swap, it's not a question of trolley vs. no trolley, either (which is the sense that I got from reading the City's description of why to do this...since it's restricted funds, we might as well spend it on this since we wouldn't be able to spend it any other way...). It could be trolley vs. expanded dial-a-ride, or trolley vs. higher service level from Get About, or trolley vs. a small local bus bringing Claremonters to the Village rather than around the Village. And there are probably other transportation needs that could be met, some of which might address a real community need while also supporting our local economy.

Another idea--if we really can't spend the money on anything of value here (or at least more valuable than the trolley), could we actually return the money? With budgets so tight, surely it could be well used somewhere else, perhaps in a City that really would run a full bus load of people from one place to another? Why just waste it? What kind of stewardship of the public trust does that represent?

Just some idle thoughts.

Thursday, January 24, 2008

Taylordum & Peterdee

On Tuesday night, the Claremont City Council approved putting the Off Track Trolley idea out to bid, no doubt pleasing Judy Wright ....er, the citizen's committee... that came up with the idea.

An old Claremontster favorite, Sonja Stump, Claremont Chamber of Commerce president, devoted Claremont 400 member, and official city council photographer (her photo of then-Councilmember Jackie McHenry ended up in a Preserve Claremont attack ad in 2005), was at Tuesday night's meeting stumping for the trolley.

The trolley, which is basically a 25-foot bus made up to look like an old-fashioned street car, will run a 1.5 mile loop with four stops from the Metrolink station and the Metrolink parking lot, to a spot near Walter's restaurant, and then over to Oberlin and the Village Expansion.

The trolley line will run three-year pilot program three days a week (Fridays through Sundays or Thursdays through Saturdays) from 11:00am to 11:30pm. The projected total cost is about $887,000. It will cost over $10 per passenger to operate, according to the city's figures.

There will be no fare to ride the trolley, and no plans at the present for advertisements.

City staff claims the cost will be paid for entirely through money from county and state funds, so it won't cost the city anything. However, if the state's budget problems get bad enough, the state may take that part of that money away, and the county money comes from sales tax revenues, which could be down significantly given the current economic downturn, especially in Claremont, where 57 percent of the sales tax is generated from auto sales. All of which could end up leaving Claremont stuck with a good chunk of the trolley bill.

Of course, the city, led by Mayor Peter Yao and Mayor Pro Tem Ellen Taylor are jumping right onto to what could end up being TrolleyGate.

The two, Yao and Taylor, seem of one mind on this and other issues, including the Base Line Rd. affordable housing project, on which neither will budge an inch.

Councilmembers Sam Pedroza and Linda Elderkin also voted in favor of the trolley. Corey Calaycay voted against it, saying he wanted to wait until the May state budget revision to see what was going to happen with that state money.

The discussion on the trolley and other topics, including the lighting of the second baseball field at College Park, was noteworthy, and we'll be up with video of some of that shortly.

We managed to capture the entire meeting from the city's live video stream, and we've been storing it and hours of other meetings, along with all future City Council meetings on the servers at the Insider's new DataCenter in a secret chamber at 207 Harvard Ave. in Claremont.

We plan on putting the video to good use and are going to hold the council (and future councils) true to their words.

Climb under the dais in the council chamber, use the secret code on the hidden panel, and you too can be an Insider:

Tuesday, April 14, 2009

Just Wondering

UPDATE, 9:00 P.M. TUESDAY:
CLAREMONT CITY COUNCIL KILLS TROLLEY


On a 3-2 vote, the Claremont City Council selected option B (see scan of staff report below). While there is still a formal resolution to be voted on at the first meeting in May, the trolley will die--go belly up--become a former trolley--at the end of the fiscal year.

Mayor pro tem Elderkin and councilmember Pedroza were on the losing end of this vote. Councilmembers Yao and Schroeder were joined by tiebreaker Mayor Calaycay to end this chapter in Claremont's history.

click to enlarge

With the Claremont Village Trolley failing to meet any measure of success (see chart above that shows the trolley's meltdown in ridership is twice as steep as the decline in the Dow Jones Industrial Average, taking only 3 to 5 months to drop 40+% instead of 6 to 10 months), it's not too surprising that City staff is recommending its continuation. In staff's option A in tonight's council report on the trolley, staff attempts to justify continuing the trolley "to maintain the committee's goal of promoting economic development within the City."

What?

Is there the slightest shred of evidence that the trolley contributes a thing to the city's economic development? We don't find anything in the staff report that would make us think that.

Just wondering.

There has never been a more flagrant waste of money. Put it out of its misery.

click to enlarge

Friday, December 28, 2007

Trolley Mail

We received a number of letters about the proposed Downtown Claremont trolley system. Recall that city staff and a citizen committee that included former Claremont Mayor Judy Wright studied the problem of linking the various commercial areas in town.

As we noted earlier this month, the trolley has been scaled back considerably from the original conception. The $887,000 three-year trial will consist of a circuit running every 15 minutes though the Claremont Village and Village Expansion [NOTE: The eventual cost of the trolley was about $1.29 million, not the $887,000 originally proposed. -ed.]. The Claremont Colleges and the Old School House at Foothill and Indian Hill Blvd. will not be included.

Using the figures tossed about by the city, the trips penciled out to over $10 per user by our estimate (15 riders per hour, 12-1/2 hours per day, three days per week, for three years equals 87,750 riders). Not much value for what amounts to a few minutes walk.

One reader wrote in to say:

I've never heard a more ridiculous idea in my life. You can walk from Three Forks to Walter's in seven minutes; who needs a trolley?

I'm a bit skeptical of the whole anti-obesity furor, but I'd bet the Claremont 400 swallows it hook, line, and sinker. And to them I say, "Is it any wonder that America is getting fat when municipalities spend nearly a million bucks to bus people six blocks?"

Another said this about City Hall in general:

I wonder if the City Council and Staff can find some money for purchasing "Seeing Eye dogs" for themselves. The blind leading the blind method just does not seem to work for them when it comes to managing the City.

The trolley's sounding like just another toy for staff to play with at your expense.

Pictured at right:
Housing and Redevelopment Manager Brian Desatnik studies a mock-up of the downtown Claremont trolley service as part of city staff's detailed proposal analysis. The trolley is a gift to Claremont from former Mayor Judy Wright as part of her legacy building project.

Thursday, August 6, 2009

Out of Sight but not Out of Mind

Where is the Trolley?

We've been asked by a few readers, "whatever happened to the Trolley?" Last we heard there was some discussion with a Trolley Brokers in Colorado, and Maybe Chaffey College over in Rancho Cucamonga. A letter from Chaffey College was even included in the agenda packet for the May 26, 2009 council meeting expressing interest if a few nettlesome details could be worked through.

Well, we tasked the Insider KH-12B spy satellite to try to pin down the geodetic coordinates of the Claremont Trolley. After poring over thousands of images identified by our state-of-the-art pattern-recognition software, and collating locations through a probabilistic image-match algorithm, we finally believe we can identify the location of the Trolley at least on pass 19,311 at 1738 UTC today, August 6, 2009.

The Trolley is sitting in a carport in the City Yard--awaiting another clarion call to duty.

See the pictures below (as usual, click on picture to enlarge):

Survey image showing Claremont and Pomona
East portion of Claremont and west part of Upland
City Yard on Monte Vista
Trolley found under camouflage cover
Detail of Trolley on August 6, 2009

Tuesday, September 2, 2008

Desert Trolley News

Trolleys have become the latest urban planner fad. Some trolley company representative must be making the rounds at League of California Cities conferences.

Claremont's trolley-folly begins in October, and now news comes to us of a proposal in Indio to include a trolley at Indio's Polo Square mixed-use development.

The Desert Sun reported on the Polo Square trolley:

Polo Square, the city's flagship project on Highway 111, will include an electric trolley system that will weave through the more than 50-acre, mixed use project.

Hailed by some as a unique feature for retail projects, the anticipated trolley system will not only ease traffic congestion, but serve as an attraction as well.

“It looks like the old double-decker buses in England,” said Janet Cook, executive director of the Indio Chamber of Commerce. “I think people will come to Polo Square to ride them.”

The project is at the corner of Shields Road and Highway 111 in what is considered one of the gateways to Indio.

The high-rise project has been marketed as a “city within a city” and may eventually include about 500 dwelling units in vertical condo buildings, two hotels, various retail boutiques, a department stores, high-end supermarket and subterranean parking.

It is estimated to cost about $850 million and is scheduled for completion in 2012.

Friday, September 12, 2008

Friday Mailbag

TROLLEY MAIL

We received a few notes in response to yesterday's post about the downtown Claremont "trackless trolley":

DATE: Thursday, September 11, 2008 5:26 PM
SUBJECT: Trolley Folly
TO: Claremont Buzz

Now we hear from the Courier article that the Trolley will cost more, that the money from Sacramento may not be forthcoming and therefore be another unbudgeted item for which the taxpayers will have to pony up the money, and all so certain former and current council members can feel like they are in San Francisco or Portland. Aren’t we supposed to be a sustainable healthy city dedicated to getting people to walk and ride their bikes? Aren’t there other trolleys (like the one in Indio, ironically) that are electric powered and therefore more “sustainable”? Are there any stores in Claremont on the trolley route that people actually have to be deposited on its doorstep before anyone will go there?

There must be better and more meaningful ways in which the Claremont City Council can spend our money ( pick your favorite) and , if not, maybe the State SHOULD take money away from them before they find another hare-brained “cute” folly on which to waste it.


And this:

DATE: Thursday, September 11, 2008 3:18 PM
SUBJECT: trolley ?
TO: Claremont Buzz

Hi, just curious if you happen to know where the city council plaque will be located on the new trolley? oh, and I heard a rumor that during the october 30 event the light refreshments will not include girl scout cookies. can you confirm?

[Name Withheld]
(if for some reason you put this on your blog, please don't include my name. don't want to be eligible for any retaliation...)


No, dear reader, we cannot confirm the plaque location, but you can count on it being gold-plated and feature the name Judy Wright prominently.

Friday, January 30, 2009

City Money Matters

In case you were wondering about Tuesday night's Claremont City Council meeting, there were a few items of interest:


COUNCIL BENEFITS TRIMMED

The Council voted unanimously to do away with the option for Councilmembers to take the unused portion of their health benefits and put it into a deferred compensation account. At last report, Councilmember Peter Yao and Mayor Ellen Taylor were the only two of the five Councilmembers receiving the health benefits, and Taylor was the only one putting the money into the deferred compensation plan.


COUNCIL SAYS "NO" TO NEW BONDS

The Council voted 4-1 against financing another million dollars through general obligation bonds to repay the city's General Fund reserve for money the City used to help buy Johnson's Pasture. That $1 million was needed after the state pulled promised grant money because of what the state felt was faulty language in the deed for the property.

Councilmember Linda Elderkin (pictured, left) was the person who pushed this agenda item, citing her worries about the city's future financial situation and the need to have that extra million in reserve. Councilmember Yao, however, pointed out that the financing fees for the bonds Elderkin was proposing amounted to $75,000. As Yao rightly asked, would you pay 7.5% in financing fees on a home loan? Additionally, the city would have been facing much higher interest rate payments on those bonds than they did when they bought the Pasture in 2007 because of the deterioration in the municipal bond market.Even Councilmember

Sam Pedroza seemed to understand that the ride on the bonded debt gravy train is over for now, especially if the city plans on asking voters in the future for $25 million or more in bonds for a police station. Pedroza said, "I get accused of saying, 'I never met a tax I didn't like.' It [Elderkin's bond proposal] looks enticing. The cookie jar's right there." And yet, in the end Pedroza voted against going for the $1 million bond.

After the vote, Councilmember Elderkin warned, "Wait until we've gotten to where there's no money left in the General Fund. Remember your vote." Perhaps Elderkin and the others, instead of looking to find more money, might try living within their means for a change. If they and past councils had done so in the first place, they wouldn't be in such dire fiscal straits now.


TROLLEY ON TRACK FOR FOUNDATION GIG

The other issue of the day was the request by the Claremont Community Foundation - the Claremont 400's charity arm - to use the Claremont Trolley for a fundraiser. The CCF wants to use the Trolley to bus people around to different historical sites in town. They plan on doing two of these tours with about 20 people per tour.

CCF Executive Director Nickie Cleaves (pictured, right) was on hand at the Council meeting Tuesday to lobby for the proposal. Cleaves said there was extra urgency because the CCF booklet advertising the event in question was at the printer's, and the event was listed in the copy.

This was a real tactical error by Cleaves and the 400, by the way. It illustrates perfectly how official Claremont decisions are supposed to work: an event gets dreamed up by former Mayor Judy Wright and is supposed to be approved without any real discussion by the Council. It's just assumed that the item will automatically pass. So much for the public process. It shows how the 400 will intentionally create a false sense of urgency to get their way: "The brochure is at the printer's. It's too late to make a change. We must pass this. If you don't vote for this important charity event, you are a heartless monster."

Two problems arose. The first, mentioned by Councilmember Yao, was the lack of any procedure for giving city resources over to private organizations. For all her talk about caring about "the process," Councilmember Elderkin, who supported lending out the trolley, conveniently ignored the fact that there was NO process at all in place here. It was completely arbitrary, which is how even things with set processes can go in Claremont anyway.

The second objection was the fact that because the trolley is garaged in a city facility funded with Federal Transit Authority grant money, the city risked getting that penalized for lending out the trolley for a private function. Apparently, federal policies restrict how municipal resources linked to federal transit funds can be used. Councilmember Corey Calaycay, who is Claremont's representative to the Foothill Transit Authority, raised this concern, citing the example of a project in Sierra Madre where similar concerns arose.

Oddly, the councilmembers (Taylor, Elderkin, and Pedroza) in favor of lending out the trolley were unconcerned with the possibility of getting penalized by the federal government. Because of the false urgency the CCF's Nickie Cleaves stirred up, the Councilmembers who favored the event did not even want to wait a week or two for an opinion from an attorney familiar with the laws governing federal transit funds (City Attorney Sonia Carvalho wisely acknowledged she didn't know enough about the subject).

In his tongue-tied way, Councilmember Pedroza (pictured, left) expressed his unconditional love for the proposal: "I feel it's a shame that we dwarf [sic] this because of a technicality." To which Mayor Taylor added with a scowl, "Say petty technicality."

Incidentally, where was the League of Women Voters on this issue? They send observers to every Council meeting, yet they will be inevitably silent on this issue. If it didn't involve the CCF, whose own governing board includes at least one League member, the LWV would have been up in arms about the lack of process and the potential risk of federal violations.

In any case, the item was approved on a 3-2 vote with Yao and Calaycay dissenting. It was unclear whether or not the vote was contingent upon the City getting a legal opinion on the issue of the federal transit funds.